TastingsTerritories and wines

Nuits-Saint-Georges and the charm of old vintages

Nuits-Saint-Georges

Marco Manzoli—aka Vinogodi —continues his journey through Burgundy in Nuits-Saint-Georges, where Pinot Noir finds winemakers capable of standing the test of time. Eight tastings from 1999 to 2005—ranging from Henri Gouges and Méo-Camuzet to the rarities of Domaine Leroy—reveal the nuances of an appellation without any Grand Cru designations, yet rich in vineyards and wines of extraordinary character.

Nuits-Saint-GeorgesTour of Nuits-Saint-Georges has held its AOC status since September 1936, but the fame of its red wines dates back much further. The Les Saint-Georges vineyard, just south of the town, has been one of the region’s hallmarks for centuries.

In 1892, the municipality—which was then simply called Nuits (a term believed to derive from the Latin nutium, walnuts), added the name of its most famous vineyard to its own, becoming Nuits-Saint-Georges. This was a common practice in wine-growing Burgundy, where the name of a cru could become part of an entire town’s identity.

Forty-one Premier Crus and no Grand Crus


The appellation includes the vineyards of Nuits-Saint-Georges and Premeaux-Prissey. According to BIVB data (
Bureau Interprofessionnel des Vins de Bourgogne, in Italian Interprofessional Office of Burgundy Wines) for 2022, the area under cultivation is just over 305 hectares, of which approximately 142 are classified as Premier Cru. Red wines made from Pinot Noir constitute the vast majority of production, alongside a small proportion of white wines. Of course, in addition to appellation wines, there are also vineyards within the boundaries of the municipality of Nuits-Saint-Georges that produce regional wines (AOC Régionale Bourgogne).

There are 41 Premier Cru-classified climat. No vineyard in the appellation is classified as Grand Cru, but this does not prevent its finest wines from reaching the very highest levels, especially when time reveals their complexity and potential for aging.

But let’s turn to some memorable tastings, going back in time. The vintages range from 1999 to 2005: bottles that demonstrate just how diverse the expressions of Nuits-Saint-Georges can be, even when made from the same grape variety.

Tastings between 1999 and 2005

Nuits-Saint-Georges Au Chouillet 1999 Jean CrotetNuits-Saint-Georges Au Chouillet 1999 Jean Crotet

DoctorWine SealScore: 95/100
Estimated price: I paid about 100 euros when it first came out; its value today is impossible to estimate

Bottled by Emmanuel Rouget, grandson of the legendary Henri Jayer, while his uncle—the most iconic producer in Burgundy’s history—was still working alongside him. Even the label design is reminiscent of that of Jayer’s wines.

100% Pinot Noir. Aged in French oak barrels (partly new or second-use) for about 12–18 months.
Its very light, transparent red color is striking. The aromas are a medley of balsamic notes, fresh porcini mushrooms, rosemary, and powdery hints. On the palate, it is almost delicate in its incredibly refined character.

Nuits-Saint-Georges Premier Cru Les Pruliers 2005, Domaine Henri GougesNuits-Saint-Georges Premier Cru Les Pruliers 2005, Domaine Henri Gouges

Score: 93/100
Approximate price: €180

A vineyard deeply rooted in the tradition of Nuits-Saint-Georges, producing wines with legendary aging potential.

100% Pinot Noir. Aged in French oak barrels for about a year, with 10–30% new oak.
Deep garnet red, with good concentration. The aromas are distinctly and beautifully tertiary, with notes of underbrush, humus, sweet licorice, and blueberry jelly. Austere on the palate, with a tannic structure that is still effective and even shows potential.

Nuits-Saint-Georges Premier Cru Aux Boudots 1999, Domaine Méo-Camuzet

DoctorWine SealScore: 95/100
Approximate price: €550

The vineyard is located on the border with Vosne-Romanée. More than twenty years after the harvest, its sensory integrity remains impressive.

100% Pinot Noir. Aged in oak barrels, including new ones, for about 16 months.
A relatively deep red color with orange highlights. Ethereal and balsamic aromas, with earthy and animal notes, and hints of cloves. On the palate, it has lively acidity and extremely smooth, velvety tannins.

Nuits-Saint-Georges Premier Cru Vieilles Vignes 2005, Domaine Prieuré RochNuits-Saint-Georges Premier Cru Vieilles Vignes 2005, Domaine Prieuré Roch

DoctorWine SealScore: 95/100
Approximate price: €800

From very old vines at Clos des Corvées, on the estate founded by Henry-Frédéric Roch, the grandson of Henry Leroy.

100% Pinot Noir. Oak barrels.
Intense red with orange hues. Once the slight volatility fades, notes of spices, garrigue, wilted roses, licorice, and sweet tobacco emerge. Velvety and smooth on the palate, supported by a still-prominent acidity.

Nuits-Saint-Georges Aux Lavières 2005 Domaine LeroyNuits-Saint-Georges Aux Lavières 2005 Domaine Leroy

DoctorWine SealScore: 96/100
Estimated price: €4,800

Here begins the series of rare wines from Domaine Leroy: lieu-dits and Premier Crus produced in very limited quantities, each offering a highly personal interpretation of the terroir.

100% Pinot Noir. New oak barrels.
A beautiful color: a very light crimson with sensual transparency. The nose is a seductive, almost hypnotic melody of incense, fine leather, honey mushrooms, and cinnamon. The palate retains great freshness, with velvety tannins of exceptional finesse and roundness.

Nuits-Saint-Georges Aux Allots 2001, Domaine LeroyNuits-Saint-Georges Aux Allots 2001, Domaine Leroy

DoctorWine SealScore: 97/100
Approximate price: €4,300

Produced in very limited quantities, this is another lieu-dit with great character in the Domaine Leroy lineup.

100% Pinot Noir. New oak barrels; aging period for the 2001 vintage not documented.

Very light red with orange highlights. Delicate yet highly complex aromas—almost like a string symphony—blending balsamic notes and spices. On the palate, it is lively thanks to its acidity, balanced by smoothness and very dense, silky tannins.

Nuits-Saint-Georges Premier Cru Les Boudots 2001, Domaine LeroyNuits-Saint-Georges Premier Cru Les Boudots 2001, Domaine Leroy

DoctorWine SealDoctorWine SealScore: 98/100
Approximate price: €4,300

A Premier Cru (from the Aux Boudots climat; “Les Boudots” appears on historic Leroy bottles) that showcases balance and refinement on the palate.

100% Pinot Noir. New oak barrels.
A very light red, almost rosé in color, with a brilliant hue. On the nose, notes of red fruit jellies, macerated violets, and roses. On the palate, the balance is surprising, supported by acidity and a magnificent mineral note on the finish, resulting in a wine of great elegance.

Nuits-Saint-Georges Premier Cru Les Vignerondes 2001 Domaine LeroyNuits-Saint-Georges Premier Cru Les Vignerondes 2001 Domaine Leroy

DoctorWine SealDoctorWine SealScore: 98/100
Approximate price: €5,000

Once again, the climat is Aux Vignerondes; Les Vignerondes appears on historic labels. Another extremely rare bottle, with just over 500 bottles produced.

100% Pinot Noir. New oak barrels.
The color is slightly deeper than that of the Boudots, but equally nuanced. An intensely aromatic nose of various flower petals, menthol notes, and oriental spices, with a strong balsamic character. The aromatic intensity is balanced by delicacy; the palate is one of dreamlike elegance, with unparalleled complexity and length.

RELATED ARTICLES

What you think about this post?